The Shorter Discourse With Māluṅkya · Translation: Bhikkhu Sujato, SuttaCentral
Parallels & more translations on SuttaCentral
neither‘Neva
existshoti
norna
notna
existshoti
a realized onetathāgato
afterparaṁ
deathmaraṇā’ti,
Māluṅkyaputtamālukyaputta,
when there is a viewdiṭṭhiyā
there beingsati
the living of the spiritual lifebrahmacariyavāso
there would beabhavissāti,
even soevampi
nono.
exists‘Hoti
andca
notna
andca
existshoti
a realized onetathāgato
afterparaṁ
deathmaraṇā’ti,
Māluṅkyaputtamālukyaputta,
when there is a viewdiṭṭhiyā
there beingsati,
neither‘neva
existshoti
norna
notna
existshoti
a realized onetathāgato
afterparaṁ
deathmaraṇā’ti
orvā
when there is a viewdiṭṭhiyā
there beingsati
there isattheva
birthjāti
……pe…
which for meyesāhaṁ
in this very lifediṭṭheva
of thingsdhamme
defeatnighātaṁ
I advocatepaññapemi.
therefore hereTasmātiha,
Māluṅkyaputtamālukyaputta,
not·declared·knowabyākatañca
by meme
not·declaredabyākatato
you should rememberdhāretha;
declared·knowbyākatañca
by meme
as declaredbyākatato
you should rememberdhāretha.
and whatKiñca,
Māluṅkyaputtamālukyaputta,
by memayā
undeclaredabyākataṁ?
eternal‘Sassato
the cosmos; quoteloko’ti
Māluṅkyaputtamālukyaputta,
by memayā
undeclaredabyākataṁ;
not eternal‘asassato
the cosmos; quoteloko’ti—
by memayā
undeclaredabyākataṁ;
finite‘antavā
the cosmos; quoteloko’ti—
by memayā
undeclaredabyākataṁ;
infinite‘anantavā
the cosmos; quoteloko’ti—
by memayā
undeclaredabyākataṁ;
that‘taṁ
souljīvaṁ
thattaṁ
body; quotesarīran’ti—
by memayā
undeclaredabyākataṁ;
one‘aññaṁ
souljīvaṁ
anotheraññaṁ
body; quotesarīran’ti—
by memayā
undeclaredabyākataṁ;
exists‘hoti
thus·gonetathāgato
afterparaṁ
death; quotemaraṇā’ti—
by memayā
undeclaredabyākataṁ;
not‘na
existshoti
thus·gonetathāgato
afterparaṁ
death; quotemaraṇā’ti—
by memayā
undeclaredabyākataṁ;
exists‘hoti
andca
notna
andca
existshoti
thus·gonetathāgato
afterparaṁ
death; quotemaraṇā’ti—
by memayā
undeclaredabyākataṁ;
neither‘neva
existshoti
notna
notna
existshoti
thus·gonetathāgato
afterparaṁ
death; quotemaraṇā’ti—
by memayā
undeclaredabyākataṁ.
whyKasmā
and thiscetaṁ,
Mālukyaputtamālukyaputta,
by memayā
not·declaredabyākataṁ?
notNa
for thishetaṁ,
Mālukyaputtamālukyaputta,
benefit·connectedatthasaṁhitaṁ
notna
beginning·spiritual-lifeādibrahmacariyakaṁ
notna
to disillusionmentnibbidāya
notna
to dispassionvirāgāya
notna
to cessationnirodhāya
notna
to peaceupasamāya
notna
to insightabhiññāya
notna
to awakeningsambodhāya
notna
to extinguishmentnibbānāya
together·turnssaṁvattati.
thereforeTasmā
thattaṁ
by memayā
not·declaredabyākataṁ.
what·andKiñca,
Mālukyaputtamālukyaputta,
by memayā
forth·madebyākataṁ?
this‘Idaṁ
sufferingdukkhan’ti,
Mālukyaputtamālukyaputta,
by memayā
forth·madebyākataṁ;
this‘ayaṁ
the origin of sufferingdukkhasamudayo’ti—
by memayā
forth·madebyākataṁ;
this‘ayaṁ
the cessation of sufferingdukkhanirodho’ti—
by memayā
forth·madebyākataṁ;
this‘ayaṁ
suffering·cessation·leadingdukkhanirodhagāminī
practicepaṭipadā’ti—
by memayā
forth·madebyākataṁ.
whyKasmā
and thiscetaṁ,
Māluṅkyaputtamālukyaputta,
by memayā
declared?byākataṁ?
for this indeedEtañhi,
Māluṅkyaputtamālukyaputta,
goal·connectedatthasaṁhitaṁ
thisetaṁ
beginning·spiritual-lifeādibrahmacariyakaṁ
to disillusionmentnibbidāya
to dispassionvirāgāya
to cessationnirodhāya
to peaceupasamāya
to insightabhiññāya
to awakeningsambodhāya
to extinguishmentnibbānāya
it leadssaṁvattati.
thereforeTasmā
thattaṁ
by memayā
declared.byākataṁ.
therefore hereTasmātiha,
Māluṅkyaputtamālukyaputta,
not·declared·andabyākatañca
by meme
as undeclaredabyākatato
you should rememberdhāretha;
declared·andbyākatañca
by meme
as declaredbyākatato
you should remember.”dhārethā”ti.
this·saidIdamavoca
the Blessed One.bhagavā.
satisfiedAttamano
Venerableāyasmā
Māluṅkyaputtamālukyaputto
of the Blessed Onebhagavato
speechbhāsitaṁ
he approved.abhinandīti.
the Shorter Discourse With MāluṅkyaCūḷamālukyasuttaṁ
finishedniṭṭhitaṁ
third.tatiyaṁ.
‹ Previous · Page 4 of 4
Lite mode — plain HTML for e-readers and old browsers. Full version