With Bhaddāli · Translation: Bhikkhu Sujato, SuttaCentral
Parallels & more translations on SuttaCentral
hereIdha
nowpana,
Bhaddālibhaddāli,
some oneekacco
monkbhikkhu
a frequent offenderabhiṇhāpattiko
ishoti
with many offensesāpattibahulo.
heSo
by the monksbhikkhūhi
being admonishedvuccamāno
not with one thing and anothernāññenaññaṁ
does not dodge the issuepaṭicarati,
distracting the discussion with irrelevant pointsbahiddhā
discussionkathaṁ
notna
does not lead awayapanāmeti,
notna
annoyance·andkopañca
hate·anddosañca
bitterness·andappaccayañca
does not displaypātukaroti,
properlysammā
proceedsvattati,
falls in linelomaṁ
he falls in linepāteti,
proceeds to get past itnetthāraṁ
proceedsvattati,
by which‘yena
Saṅghasaṅgho
pleasedattamano
ishoti
thattaṁ
I dokaromī’ti
saysāha.
in that caseTatra,
Bhaddālibhaddāli,
of the monksbhikkhūnaṁ
thusevaṁ
ishoti:
this‘ayaṁ
indeedkho,
reverendsāvuso,
monkbhikkhu
a frequent offenderabhiṇhāpattiko
with many offensesāpattibahulo.
heSo
by the monksbhikkhūhi
being admonishedvuccamāno
not with one thing and anothernāññenaññaṁ
does not dodge the issuepaṭicarati,
distracting the discussion with irrelevant pointsbahiddhā
discussionkathaṁ
notna
does not lead awayapanāmeti,
notna
annoyance·andkopañca
hate·anddosañca
bitterness·andappaccayañca
does not displaypātukaroti,
properlysammā
proceedsvattati,
falls in linelomaṁ
he falls in linepāteti,
proceeds to get past itnetthāraṁ
proceedsvattati,
by which“yena
Saṅghasaṅgho
pleasedattamano
ishoti
thattaṁ
I dokaromī”ti
saysāha.
goodSādhu
venerable sirsvatāyasmanto,
thisimassa
monkbhikkhuno
in such a waytathā
in such a waytathā
you should examineupaparikkhatha
as + thisyathāssidaṁ
disciplinary issueadhikaraṇaṁ
quick + justkhippameva
would be settledvūpasameyyā’ti.
of thatTassa
indeedkho
thusevaṁ,
Bhaddālibhaddāli,
monkbhikkhuno
monksbhikkhū
in such a waytathā
in such a waytathā
examineupaparikkhanti
as + thisyathāssidaṁ
disciplinary issueadhikaraṇaṁ
quick + justkhippameva
is settledvūpasammati.
hereIdha,
Bhaddālibhaddāli,
someekacco
monkbhikkhu
an occasional offenderadhiccāpattiko
ishoti
without many offensesanāpattibahulo.
heSo
by the monksbhikkhūhi
being admonishedvuccamāno
the issueaññenaññaṁ
dodgespaṭicarati,
outsidebahiddhā
the talkkathaṁ
divertsapanāmeti,
and angerkopañca
and ill willdosañca
and discontentappaccayañca
revealspātukaroti,
notna
properlysammā
he behavesvattati,
notna
compliantlylomaṁ
he actspāteti,
notna
the settlementnetthāraṁ
he proceeds tovattati,
by which‘yena
the Saṅghasaṅgho
satisfiedattamano
ishoti
thattaṁ
I dokaromī’ti
he does not saynāha.
thereTatra,
Bhaddālibhaddāli,
of the monksbhikkhūnaṁ
thusevaṁ
it ishoti:
this‘ayaṁ
indeedkho,
reverendsāvuso,
monkbhikkhu
an occasional offenderadhiccāpattiko
without many offensesanāpattibahulo.
heSo
by the monksbhikkhūhi
being admonishedvuccamāno
the issueaññenaññaṁ
dodgespaṭicarati,
outsidebahiddhā
the talkkathaṁ
divertsapanāmeti,
and angerkopañca
and ill willdosañca
and discontentappaccayañca
revealspātukaroti,
notna
properlysammā
he behavesvattati,
notna
compliantlylomaṁ
he actspāteti,
notna
the settlementnetthāraṁ
he proceeds tovattati,
by which“yena
the Saṅghasaṅgho
satisfiedattamano
ishoti
thattaṁ
I dokaromī”ti
he does not saynāha.
It would be goodSādhu
indeed, venerablesvatāyasmanto,
of thisimassa
monkbhikkhuno
in such a waytathā
in such a waytathā
you should examineupaparikkhatha
that thisyathāssidaṁ
disciplinary issueadhikaraṇaṁ
notna
quicklykhippameva
would be settledvūpasameyyā’ti.
of thatTassa
indeedkho
thusevaṁ,
Bhaddālibhaddāli,
monkbhikkhuno
the monksbhikkhū
in such a waytathā
in such a waytathā
examineupaparikkhanti
that thisyathāssidaṁ
disciplinary issueadhikaraṇaṁ
notna
quicklykhippameva
is settledvūpasammati.
hereIdha
nowpana,
Bhaddālibhaddāli,
some oneekacco
monkbhikkhu
occasional·offenderadhiccāpattiko
ishoti
without many offensesanāpattibahulo.
heSo
by the monksbhikkhūhi
being admonishedvuccamāno
doesn’t dodge the issuenāññenaññaṁ
dodgespaṭicarati,
notna
outsidebahiddhā
talkkathaṁ
leads awayapanāmeti,
notna
anger andkopañca
ill-will anddosañca
displeasure andappaccayañca
revealspātukaroti,
properlysammā
behavesvattati,
bristlinglomaṁ
causespāteti,
redressnetthāraṁ
behavesvattati,
by which‘yena
the Saṅghasaṅgho
satisfiedattamano
ishoti
thattaṁ
I dokaromī’ti
saysāha.
in that caseTatra,
Bhaddālibhaddāli,
of the monksbhikkhūnaṁ
thusevaṁ
occurshoti:
this‘ayaṁ
indeedkho,
reverendsāvuso,
monkbhikkhu
occasional·offenderadhiccāpattiko
without many offensesanāpattibahulo.
heSo
by the monksbhikkhūhi
being admonishedvuccamāno
doesn’t dodge the issuenāññenaññaṁ
dodgespaṭicarati,
notna
outsidebahiddhā
talkkathaṁ
leads awayapanāmeti,
notna
anger andkopañca
ill-will anddosañca
displeasure andappaccayañca
revealspātukaroti,
properlysammā
behavesvattati,
bristlinglomaṁ
causespāteti,
redressnetthāraṁ
behavesvattati,
by which“yena
the Saṅghasaṅgho
satisfiedattamano
ishoti
thattaṁ
I dokaromī”ti
saysāha.
goodSādhu
venerablesvatāyasmanto,
of thisimassa
monkbhikkhuno
suchtathā
suchtathā
examineupaparikkhatha
so-that + thisyathāssidaṁ
disciplinary issueadhikaraṇaṁ
quicklykhippameva
would be settledvūpasameyyā’ti.
of thisTassa
indeedkho
thusevaṁ,
Bhaddālibhaddāli,
monkbhikkhuno
the monksbhikkhū
suchtathā
suchtathā
examineupaparikkhanti
so-that + thisyathāssidaṁ
disciplinary issueadhikaraṇaṁ
quicklykhippameva
is settledvūpasammati.
hereIdha,
Bhaddālibhaddāli,
someekacco
monkbhikkhu
with mere faithsaddhāmattakena
gets byvahati
with mere fondnesspemamattakena.
thereTatra,
Bhaddālibhaddāli,
of the monksbhikkhūnaṁ
thusevaṁ
it ishoti:
this‘ayaṁ
indeedkho,
reverendsāvuso,
monkbhikkhu
with mere faithsaddhāmattakena
gets byvahati
with mere fondnesspemamattakena.
ifSace
wemayaṁ
thisimaṁ
monkbhikkhuṁ
pressuringpasayha
pressuringpasayha
a punishmentkāraṇaṁ
we will dokarissāma—
do notmā
of hisyampissa
thattaṁ
mere faithsaddhāmattakaṁ
mere fondnesspemamattakaṁ
from thattamhāpi
let him loseparihāyī’ti.
as·justSeyyathāpi,
Bhaddālibhaddāli,
of a personpurisassa
oneekaṁ
eyecakkhuṁ,
histassa
friend·colleaguemittāmaccā
relative·kinñātisālohitā
thattaṁ
oneekaṁ
eyecakkhuṁ
would protectrakkheyyuṁ:
let not‘mā
which·alsoyampissa
thattaṁ
oneekaṁ
eyecakkhuṁ
from that·eventamhāpi
should loseparihāyī’ti;
thus·justevameva
indeedkho,
Bhaddālibhaddāli,
here someidhekacco
monkbhikkhu
faith·meresaddhāmattakena
gets byvahati
fondness·merepemamattakena.
in such a caseTatra,
Bhaddālibhaddāli,
of the monksbhikkhūnaṁ
thusevaṁ
there ishoti:
this‘ayaṁ
indeedkho,
reverendsāvuso,
monkbhikkhu
faith·meresaddhāmattakena
gets byvahati
fondness·merepemamattakena.
ifSace
wemayaṁ
thisimaṁ
monkbhikkhuṁ
forth·overcomepasayha
forth·overcomepasayha
actionkāraṇaṁ
we will dokarissāma—
let notmā
which·alsoyampissa
thattaṁ
faith·meresaddhāmattakaṁ
fondness·merepemamattakaṁ
from that·eventamhāpi
should loseparihāyī’ti.
thisAyaṁ
indeedkho,
Bhaddālibhaddāli,
causehetu
thisayaṁ
reasonpaccayo
by whichyena
here·somemidhekaccaṁ
monkbhikkhuṁ
forth·overcomepasayha
forth·overcomepasayha
actionkāraṇaṁ
they dokaronti.
thisAyaṁ
butpana,
Bhaddālibhaddāli,
causehetu
thisayaṁ
reasonpaccayo,
by whichyena
here·somemidhekaccaṁ
monkbhikkhuṁ
notno
similarlytathā
forth·overcomepasayha
forth·overcomepasayha
actionkāraṇaṁ
they dokarontī”ti.
‹ Previous · Page 4 of 5 · Next ›
Lite mode — plain HTML for e-readers and old browsers. Full version