At Devadaha · Translation: Bhikkhu Sujato, SuttaCentral
Parallels & more translations on SuttaCentral
of those of such doctrineEvaṁvādīnaṁ,
monksbhikkhave,
of the Jainsnigaṇṭhānaṁ
theseime
tendasa
legitimatesahadhammikā
rebuttals and criticismsvādānuvādā
deservinggārayhaṁ
groundṭhānaṁ
they come toāgacchanti.
thusEvaṁ
indeedkho,
monksbhikkhave,
fruitlessaphalo
exertionupakkamo
ishoti,
fruitlessaphalaṁ
strivingpadhānaṁ.
and howKathañca,
monksbhikkhave,
fruitfulsaphalo
exertionupakkamo
ishoti,
fruitfulsaphalaṁ
strivingpadhānaṁ?
hereIdha,
monksbhikkhave,
a mendicantbhikkhu
notna
indeed notheva
not brought to sufferinganaddhabhūtaṁ
selfattānaṁ
with sufferingdukkhena
brings to sufferingaddhabhāveti,
and legitimatedhammikañca
pleasuresukhaṁ
notna
forsakespariccajati,
and in thattasmiñca
in pleasuresukhe
not besottedanadhimucchito
ishoti.
heSo
thusevaṁ
understandspajānāti:
of this‘imassa
indeedkho
of meme
source of sufferingdukkhanidānassa
activitysaṅkhāraṁ
actively strivingpadahato
through active strivingsaṅkhārappadhānā
dispassionvirāgo
ishoti,
of thisimassa
butpana
of meme
source of sufferingdukkhanidānassa
looking on with equanimityajjhupekkhato
equanimityupekkhaṁ
developingbhāvayato
dispassionvirāgo
ishotī’ti.
heSo
for whomyassa
indeedhi
for him indeedkhvāssa
source of sufferingdukkhanidānassa
activitysaṅkhāraṁ
actively strivingpadahato
through active strivingsaṅkhārappadhānā
dispassionvirāgo
ishoti,
activitysaṅkhāraṁ
theretattha
actively strivespadahati.
for whomYassa
but for himpanassa
source of sufferingdukkhanidānassa
looking on with equanimityajjhupekkhato
equanimityupekkhaṁ
developingbhāvayato
dispassionvirāgo
ishoti,
equanimityupekkhaṁ
theretattha
developsbhāveti.
for himTassa
for thattassa
source of sufferingdukkhanidānassa
activitysaṅkhāraṁ
actively strivingpadahato
through active strivingsaṅkhārappadhānā
dispassionvirāgo
ishoti—
thus for himevampissa
thattaṁ
sufferingdukkhaṁ
worn awaynijjiṇṇaṁ
ishoti.
for himTassa
for thattassa
source of sufferingdukkhanidānassa
looking on with equanimityajjhupekkhato
equanimityupekkhaṁ
developingbhāvayato
dispassionvirāgo
ishoti—
thus for himevampissa
thattaṁ
sufferingdukkhaṁ
worn awaynijjiṇṇaṁ
ishoti.
just asSeyyathāpi,
mendicantsbhikkhave,
a manpuriso
with a womanitthiyā
in lovesāratto
full of desirepaṭibaddhacitto
full of intense desiretibbacchando
full of lusttibbāpekkho.
heSo
thattaṁ
womanitthiṁ
would seepasseyya
with anotheraññena
manpurisena
togethersaddhiṁ
standingsantiṭṭhantiṁ
chattingsallapantiṁ
gigglingsañjagghantiṁ
laughingsaṁhasantiṁ.
thatTaṁ
whatkiṁ
do you thinkmaññatha,
mendicantsbhikkhave,
wouldapi
thennu
for thattassa
manpurisassa
thatamuṁ
womanitthiṁ
having seendisvā
with anotheraññena
manpurisena
togethersaddhiṁ
standingsantiṭṭhantiṁ
chattingsallapantiṁ
gigglingsañjagghantiṁ
laughingsaṁhasantiṁ
would ariseuppajjeyyuṁ
sorrow, lamentation, pain, sadness, and distresssokaparidevadukkhadomanassūpāyāsā”ti?
Yes“Evaṁ,
sirbhante”.
that“Taṁ
of whatkissa
causehetu”?
that“Amu
indeedhi,
sirbhante,
manpuriso
with thatamussā
womanitthiyā
in lovesāratto
full of desirepaṭibaddhacitto
full of intense desiretibbacchando
full of lusttibbāpekkho.
thereforeTasmā
thattaṁ
womanitthiṁ
having seendisvā
with anotheraññena
manpurisena
togethersaddhiṁ
standingsantiṭṭhantiṁ
chattingsallapantiṁ
gigglingsañjagghantiṁ
laughingsaṁhasantiṁ
would ariseuppajjeyyuṁ
sorrow, lamentation, pain, sadness, and distresssokaparidevadukkhadomanassūpāyāsā”ti.
then“Atha
indeedkho,
monksbhikkhave,
of thattassa
of the manpurisassa
it might be thusevamassa:
I‘ahaṁ
indeedkho
for thatamussā
of the womanitthiyā
in lovesāratto
with mind boundpaṭibaddhacitto
with intense desiretibbacchando
with intense longingtibbāpekkho.
of thatTassa
for meme
thatamuṁ
womanitthiṁ
having seendisvā
with anotheraññena
with a manpurisena
togethersaddhiṁ
standing togethersantiṭṭhantiṁ
chattingsallapantiṁ
gigglingsañjagghantiṁ
laughingsaṁhasantiṁ
ariseuppajjanti
sorrow, lamentation, pain, sadness, and distresssokaparidevadukkhadomanassūpāyāsā.
why don't IYannūnāhaṁ
whichyo
for meme
for thatamussā
of the womanitthiyā
desire and lustchandarāgo
thattaṁ
I might abandonpajaheyyan’ti.
heSo
whichyo
for thatamussā
of the womanitthiyā
desire and lustchandarāgo
thattaṁ
he would abandonpajaheyya.
heSo
thattaṁ
womanitthiṁ
he would seepasseyya
by lateraparena
timesamayena
with anotheraññena
with a manpurisena
togethersaddhiṁ
standing togethersantiṭṭhantiṁ
chattingsallapantiṁ
gigglingsañjagghantiṁ
laughingsaṁhasantiṁ.
thatTaṁ
whatkiṁ
do you thinkmaññatha,
monksbhikkhave,
wouldapi
thennu
of thattassa
of the manpurisassa
thatamuṁ
womanitthiṁ
having seendisvā
with anotheraññena
with a manpurisena
togethersaddhiṁ
standing togethersantiṭṭhantiṁ
chattingsallapantiṁ
gigglingsañjagghantiṁ
laughingsaṁhasantiṁ
would ariseuppajjeyyuṁ
sorrow, lamentation, pain, sadness, and distresssokaparidevadukkhadomanassūpāyāsā”ti?
no“No
indeed thathetaṁ,
sirbhante”.
that“Taṁ
of whatkissa
causehetu”?
that“Amu
indeedhi,
sirbhante,
manpuriso
for thatamussā
of the womanitthiyā
free of desirevirāgo.
thereforeTasmā thattaṁ womanitthiṁ having seendisvā with anotheraññena with a manpurisena togethersaddhiṁ standing togethersantiṭṭhantiṁ conversingsallapantiṁ laughing togethersañjagghantiṁ jesting togethersaṁhasantiṁ notna would ariseuppajjeyyuṁ sorrow, lamentation, pain, grief and despair”sokaparidevadukkhadomanassūpāyāsā”ti.
just so“Evameva
indeedkho,
O monksbhikkhave,
a monkbhikkhu
notna
indeedheva
unafflictedanaddhabhūtaṁ
himselfattānaṁ
with sufferingdukkhena
causes to be afflictedaddhabhāveti,
and legitimatedhammikañca
pleasuresukhaṁ
notna
forsakespariccajati,
and in thattasmiñca
pleasuresukhe
not besottedanadhimucchito
ishoti.
heSo
thusevaṁ
understandspajānāti:
of this‘imassa
indeedkho
for meme
source of sufferingdukkhanidānassa
activitysaṅkhāraṁ
actively strivingpadahato
from active strivingsaṅkhārappadhānā
dispassionvirāgo
ishoti,
of thisimassa
butpana
for meme
source of sufferingdukkhanidānassa
being equanimousajjhupekkhato
equanimityupekkhaṁ
developingbhāvayato
dispassionvirāgo
ishotī’ti.
heSo
for whichyassa
indeedhi
for himkhvāssa
source of sufferingdukkhanidānassa
activitysaṅkhāraṁ
actively strivingpadahato
from active strivingsaṅkhārappadhānā
dispassionvirāgo
ishoti,
activitysaṅkhāraṁ
theretattha
strivespadahati;
for whichyassa
but for himpanassa
source of sufferingdukkhanidānassa
being equanimousajjhupekkhato
equanimityupekkhaṁ
developingbhāvayato
dispassionvirāgo
ishoti,
equanimityupekkhaṁ
theretattha
developsbhāveti.
for himTassa
for himtassa
source of sufferingdukkhanidānassa
activitysaṅkhāraṁ
actively strivingpadahato
from active strivingsaṅkhārappadhānā
dispassionvirāgo
ishoti—
and thus for himevampissa
thattaṁ
sufferingdukkhaṁ
worn awaynijjiṇṇaṁ
ishoti.
for himTassa
for himtassa
source of sufferingdukkhanidānassa
being equanimousajjhupekkhato
equanimityupekkhaṁ
developingbhāvayato
dispassionvirāgo
ishoti—
and thus for himevampissa
thattaṁ
sufferingdukkhaṁ
worn awaynijjiṇṇaṁ
ishoti.
Thus tooEvampi,
O monksbhikkhave,
fruitfulsaphalo
exertionupakkamo
ishoti,
fruitfulsaphalaṁ
strivingpadhānaṁ.
furthermorePuna
and moreovercaparaṁ,
monksbhikkhave,
a mendicantbhikkhu
thusiti
reflectspaṭisañcikkhati:
as I please‘yathāsukhaṁ
indeedkho
for meme
livingviharato
unskillfulakusalā
qualitiesdhammā
growabhivaḍḍhanti,
skillfulkusalā
qualitiesdhammā
declineparihāyanti;
painfullydukkhāya
butpana
for meme
myselfattānaṁ
strivingpadahato
unskillfulakusalā
qualitiesdhammā
declineparihāyanti,
skillfulkusalā
qualitiesdhammā
growabhivaḍḍhanti.
why don't IYannūnāhaṁ
painfullydukkhāya
myselfattānaṁ
I should strivepadaheyyan’ti.
heSo
painfullydukkhāya
himselfattānaṁ
strivespadahati.
of himTassa
painfullydukkhāya
himselfattānaṁ
strivingpadahato
unskillfulakusalā
qualitiesdhammā
declineparihāyanti
skillfulkusalā
qualitiesdhammā
growabhivaḍḍhanti.
heSo
notna
lateraparena
timesamayena
painfullydukkhāya
himselfattānaṁ
strivespadahati.
thatTaṁ
of whatkissa
reasonhetu?
for himYassa
indeedhi
whoso,
monksbhikkhave,
a mendicantbhikkhu
for the sake ofatthāya
painfullydukkhāya
himselfattānaṁ
might strivepadaheyya
for him thatsvāssa
goalattho
accomplishedabhinipphanno
ishoti.
thereforeTasmā
notna
lateraparena
timesamayena
painfullydukkhāya
himselfattānaṁ
strivespadahati.
‹ Previous · Page 5 of 8 · Next ›
Lite mode — plain HTML for e-readers and old browsers. Full version