At Devadaha · Translation: Bhikkhu Sujato, SuttaCentral
Parallels & more translations on SuttaCentral
one who speaks thus tooEvaṁvādīpi indeedkho Iahaṁ, O monksbhikkhave, among the Jainsnigaṇṭhesu notna anykañci legitimatesahadhammikaṁ defense of doctrinevādapaṭihāraṁ I seesamanupassāmi.
againPuna
and furthercaparāhaṁ,
monksbhikkhave,
thosete
Jain asceticsnigaṇṭhe
thusevaṁ
I sayvadāmi:
that‘taṁ
whatkiṁ
do you think, reverendsmaññathāvuso
Jain asceticsnigaṇṭhā,
that which, thisyamidaṁ
deedkammaṁ
to be experienced in this lifediṭṭhadhammavedanīyaṁ
thattaṁ
by exertionupakkamena
orvā
by strivingpadhānena
orvā
to be experienced in lives to comesamparāyavedanīyaṁ
let it be; quotation markerhotūti
can this be gottenlabbhametan’ti?
no‘No
indeed, thishidaṁ,
reverendāvuso’.
but‘Yaṁ
but thispanidaṁ
deedkammaṁ
to be experienced in lives to comesamparāyavedanīyaṁ
thattaṁ
by exertionupakkamena
orvā
by strivingpadhānena
orvā
to be experienced in this lifediṭṭhadhammavedanīyaṁ
let it be; quotation markerhotūti
can this be gottenlabbhametan’ti?
no‘No
indeed, thishidaṁ,
reverendāvuso’.
that‘Taṁ
what?kiṁ
do you think, reverendsmaññathāvuso
Nigaṇṭhasnigaṇṭhā,
that which here isyamidaṁ
deedkammaṁ
to be experienced as pleasantsukhavedanīyaṁ
thattaṁ
by exertionupakkamena
orvā
by effortpadhānena
orvā
to be experienced as painfuldukkhavedanīyaṁ
let it behotūti
can this be obtained?labbhametan’ti?
No‘No
indeed thishidaṁ,
reverendāvuso’.
which‘Yaṁ
but this herepanidaṁ
deedkammaṁ
to be experienced as painfuldukkhavedanīyaṁ
thattaṁ
by exertionupakkamena
orvā
by effortpadhānena
orvā
to be experienced as pleasantsukhavedanīyaṁ
let it behotūti
can this be obtained?labbhametan’ti?
No‘No
indeed thishidaṁ,
reverendāvuso’.
that‘Taṁ
what?kiṁ
do you think, reverendsmaññathāvuso
Nigaṇṭhasnigaṇṭhā,
which indeed thisyamidaṁ
deedkammaṁ
to be experienced when ripeparipakkavedanīyaṁ
thattaṁ
by exertionupakkamena
orvā
by strivingpadhānena
orvā
to be experienced when unripeaparipakkavedanīyaṁ
let it be; quotation markerhotūti
is it possible?labbhametan’ti?
no‘No
indeed, reverendhidaṁ,
reverendāvuso’.
which‘Yaṁ
but indeed thispanidaṁ
deedkammaṁ
to be experienced when unripeaparipakkavedanīyaṁ
thattaṁ
by exertionupakkamena
orvā
by strivingpadhānena
orvā
to be experienced when ripeparipakkavedanīyaṁ
let it be; quotation markerhotūti
is it possible?labbhametan’ti?
no‘No
indeed, reverendhidaṁ,
reverendāvuso’.
that‘Taṁ
what?kiṁ
do you think, reverends?maññathāvuso
Nigaṇṭhas,nigaṇṭhā,
that which is thisyamidaṁ
deedkammaṁ
to be experienced a lotbahuvedanīyaṁ
thattaṁ
by exertionupakkamena
orvā
by effortpadhānena
orvā
to be experienced a littleappavedanīyaṁ
let it be, they sayhotūti
this is possible?labbhametan’ti?
no‘No
indeed,hidaṁ,
reverend.āvuso’.
that which‘Yaṁ
but thispanidaṁ
deedkammaṁ
to be experienced a littleappavedanīyaṁ
thattaṁ
by exertionupakkamena
orvā
by effortpadhānena
orvā
to be experienced a lotbahuvedanīyaṁ
let it be, they sayhotūti
this is possible?labbhametan’ti?
no‘No
indeed,hidaṁ,
reverend.āvuso’.
'that‘Taṁ
what?kiṁ
do you think, reverends?maññathāvuso
Nigaṇṭhas,nigaṇṭhā,
that which hereyamidaṁ
deedkammaṁ
to be experiencedsavedanīyaṁ
thattaṁ
by exertionupakkamena
orvā
by strivingpadhānena
orvā
not to be experiencedavedanīyaṁ
may it be so?hotūti
is that possible?'labbhametan’ti?
'No‘No
indeed,hidaṁ,
reverend'.āvuso’.
'But‘Yaṁ
that which herepanidaṁ
deedkammaṁ
not to be experiencedavedanīyaṁ
thattaṁ
by exertionupakkamena
orvā
by strivingpadhānena
orvā
to be experiencedsavedanīyaṁ
may it be so?hotūti
is that possible?'labbhametan’ti?
'No‘No
indeed,hidaṁ,
reverend'.āvuso’.
thus‘Iti indeedkira, friendāvuso Nigaṇṭhasnigaṇṭhā, that whichyamidaṁ kammakammaṁ to be felt here and nowdiṭṭhadhammavedanīyaṁ thattaṁ by exertionupakkamena orvā by strivingpadhānena orvā to be felt in a future lifesamparāyavedanīyaṁ may it behotūti this is impossiblealabbhametaṁ, whichyaṁ but thispanidaṁ kammakammaṁ to be felt in a future lifesamparāyavedanīyaṁ thattaṁ by exertionupakkamena orvā by strivingpadhānena orvā to be felt here and nowdiṭṭhadhammavedanīyaṁ may it behotūti this is impossiblealabbhametaṁ, that whichyamidaṁ kammakammaṁ to be felt as pleasantsukhavedanīyaṁ thattaṁ by exertionupakkamena orvā by strivingpadhānena orvā to be felt as painfuldukkhavedanīyaṁ may it behotūti this is impossiblealabbhametaṁ, that whichyamidaṁ kammakammaṁ to be felt as painfuldukkhavedanīyaṁ thattaṁ by exertionupakkamena orvā by strivingpadhānena orvā to be felt as pleasantsukhavedanīyaṁ may it behotūti this is impossiblealabbhametaṁ, that whichyamidaṁ kammakammaṁ to be felt when matureparipakkavedanīyaṁ thattaṁ by exertionupakkamena orvā by strivingpadhānena orvā to be felt when immatureaparipakkavedanīyaṁ may it behotūti this is impossiblealabbhametaṁ, that whichyamidaṁ kammakammaṁ to be felt when immatureaparipakkavedanīyaṁ thattaṁ by exertionupakkamena orvā by strivingpadhānena orvā to be felt when matureparipakkavedanīyaṁ may it behotūti this is impossiblealabbhametaṁ, that whichyamidaṁ kammakammaṁ to be felt as muchbahuvedanīyaṁ thattaṁ by exertionupakkamena orvā by strivingpadhānena orvā to be felt as littleappavedanīyaṁ may it behotūti this is impossiblealabbhametaṁ, that whichyamidaṁ kammakammaṁ to be felt as littleappavedanīyaṁ thattaṁ by exertionupakkamena orvā by strivingpadhānena orvā to be felt as muchbahuvedanīyaṁ may it behotūti this is impossiblealabbhametaṁ, that whichyamidaṁ kammakammaṁ to be feltsavedanīyaṁ thattaṁ by exertionupakkamena orvā by strivingpadhānena orvā not to be feltavedanīyaṁ may it behotūti this is impossiblealabbhametaṁ, that whichyamidaṁ kammakammaṁ not to be feltavedanīyaṁ thattaṁ by exertionupakkamena orvā by strivingpadhānena orvā to be feltsavedanīyaṁ may it behotūti this is impossiblealabbhametaṁ;
thusevaṁ being sosante venerable onesāyasmantānaṁ of the Nigaṇṭhasnigaṇṭhānaṁ fruitlessaphalo exertionupakkamo ishoti, fruitlessaphalaṁ strivingpadhānaṁ’.
speaking thusEvaṁvādī,
monksbhikkhave,
Jain asceticsnigaṇṭhā.
of those speaking thusEvaṁvādīnaṁ,
monksbhikkhave,
of the Jain asceticsnigaṇṭhānaṁ
tendasa
legitimatesahadhammikā
grounds for rebuttal and criticismvādānuvādā
deserving of censuregārayhaṁ
groundṭhānaṁ
they come toāgacchanti.
ifSace,
monksbhikkhave,
sentient beingssattā
because of past deedspubbekatahetu
pleasure and painsukhadukkhaṁ
they experiencepaṭisaṁvedenti;
clearlyaddhā,
monksbhikkhave,
the Jain asceticsnigaṇṭhā
in the pastpubbe
doers of bad deedsdukkaṭakammakārino
sinceyaṁ
nowetarahi
suchevarūpā
painfuldukkhā
sharptibbā
bitingkaṭukā
painful feelingsvedanā
they experiencevediyanti.
ifSace,
monksbhikkhave,
sentient beingssattā
because of God Almighty's creationissaranimmānahetu
pleasure and painsukhadukkhaṁ
they experiencepaṭisaṁvedenti;
clearlyaddhā,
monksbhikkhave,
the Jain asceticsnigaṇṭhā
by a bad Godpāpakena
by Godissarena
creatednimmitā
sinceyaṁ
nowetarahi
suchevarūpā
painfuldukkhā
sharptibbā
bitingkaṭukā
painful feelingsvedanā
they experiencevediyanti.
ifSace,
monksbhikkhave,
sentient beingssattā
because of circumstance and naturesaṅgatibhāvahetu
pleasure and painsukhadukkhaṁ
they experiencepaṭisaṁvedenti;
clearlyaddhā,
monksbhikkhave,
the Jain asceticsnigaṇṭhā
arising from bad circumstancespāpasaṅgatikā
sinceyaṁ
nowetarahi
suchevarūpā
painfuldukkhā
sharptibbā
bitingkaṭukā
painful feelingsvedanā
they experiencevediyanti.
ifSace,
monksbhikkhave,
sentient beingssattā
because of the class of rebirthabhijātihetu
pleasure and painsukhadukkhaṁ
they experiencepaṭisaṁvedenti;
clearlyaddhā,
monksbhikkhave,
the Jain asceticsnigaṇṭhā
reborn in a bad classpāpābhijātikā
sinceyaṁ
nowetarahi
suchevarūpā
painfuldukkhā
sharptibbā
bitingkaṭukā
painful feelingsvedanā
they experiencevediyanti.
ifSace,
monksbhikkhave,
sentient beingssattā
because of exertion in this lifediṭṭhadhammūpakkamahetu
pleasure and painsukhadukkhaṁ
they experiencepaṭisaṁvedenti;
surelyaddhā,
monksbhikkhave,
the Jainsnigaṇṭhā
of such kindevarūpā
exerting in this lifediṭṭhadhammūpakkamā
sinceyaṁ
nowetarahi
of such kindevarūpā
painfuldukkhā
sharptibbā
bitingkaṭukā
feelingsvedanā
they experiencevediyanti.
ifSace,
monksbhikkhave,
beingssattā
because of past deedspubbekatahetu
pleasure and painsukhadukkhaṁ
they experiencepaṭisaṁvedenti,
blameworthygārayhā
the Jainsnigaṇṭhā;
notno
ifce
beingssattā
because of past deedspubbekatahetu
pleasure and painsukhadukkhaṁ
they experiencepaṭisaṁvedenti,
blameworthygārayhā
the Jainsnigaṇṭhā.
ifSace,
monksbhikkhave,
beingssattā
because of creation by a lordissaranimmānahetu
pleasure and painsukhadukkhaṁ
they experiencepaṭisaṁvedenti,
blameworthygārayhā
the Jainsnigaṇṭhā;
notno
ifce
beingssattā
because of creation by a lordissaranimmānahetu
pleasure and painsukhadukkhaṁ
they experiencepaṭisaṁvedenti,
blameworthygārayhā
the Jainsnigaṇṭhā.
ifSace,
monksbhikkhave,
beingssattā
because of circumstance and naturesaṅgatibhāvahetu
pleasure and painsukhadukkhaṁ
they experiencepaṭisaṁvedenti,
blameworthygārayhā
the Jainsnigaṇṭhā;
notno
ifce
beingssattā
because of circumstance and naturesaṅgatibhāvahetu
pleasure and painsukhadukkhaṁ
they experiencepaṭisaṁvedenti,
blameworthygārayhā
the Jainsnigaṇṭhā.
ifSace,
monksbhikkhave,
beingssattā
because of class of rebirthabhijātihetu
pleasure and painsukhadukkhaṁ
they experiencepaṭisaṁvedenti,
blameworthygārayhā
the Jainsnigaṇṭhā;
notno
ifce
beingssattā
because of class of rebirthabhijātihetu
pleasure and painsukhadukkhaṁ
they experiencepaṭisaṁvedenti,
blameworthygārayhā
the Jainsnigaṇṭhā.
ifSace,
monksbhikkhave,
beingssattā
because of exertion in this lifediṭṭhadhammūpakkamahetu
pleasure and painsukhadukkhaṁ
they experiencepaṭisaṁvedenti,
blameworthygārayhā
the Jainsnigaṇṭhā;
notno
ifce
beingssattā
because of exertion in this lifediṭṭhadhammūpakkamahetu
pleasure and painsukhadukkhaṁ
they experiencepaṭisaṁvedenti,
blameworthygārayhā
the Jainsnigaṇṭhā.
speaking thusEvaṁvādī,
monksbhikkhave,
the Jainsnigaṇṭhā.
‹ Previous · Page 4 of 8 · Next ›
Lite mode — plain HTML for e-readers and old browsers. Full version