The Five and Three · Translation: Bhikkhu Sujato, SuttaCentral
Parallels & more translations on SuttaCentral
just asSeyyathāpi
indeednāma
of a tradervāṇijassa
for tradingvāṇijjāya
goinggacchato
thusevaṁ
it occurshoti:
from this‘ito
for meme
thisidaṁ
will bebhavissati,
with thisiminā
thisidaṁ
I shall getlacchāmī’ti;
just·these + theseevamevime
sirsbhonto
ascetic·and·brahminsamaṇabrāhmaṇā
trader·likevāṇijūpamā
I thinkmaññe
they appearpaṭibhanti:
thus‘iti
after deathpecca
we will bebhavissāma,
thusiti
after deathpecca
we will bebhavissāmā’ti.
that thisTayidaṁ,
monksbhikkhave,
thus·gonetathāgato
understandsabhijānāti.
thoseYe
indeedkho
thosete
sirsbhonto
ascetic·and·brahminsamaṇabrāhmaṇā
of an existingsato
beingsattassa
annihilationucchedaṁ
eradicationvināsaṁ
non·existencevibhavaṁ
they assertpaññapenti
thosete
from fear of substantial realitysakkāyabhayā
from disgust with substantial realitysakkāyaparijegucchā
around substantial reality itselfsakkāyaññeva
along·around·runanuparidhāvanti
they keep circling aroundanuparivattanti.
just asSeyyathāpi
indeednāma
thatsā
leash·boundgaddulabaddho
to a strongdaḷhe
postthambhe
orvā
pillarkhile
orvā
tetheredupanibaddho,
that + sametameva
postthambhaṁ
orvā
pillarkhilaṁ
orvā
along·around·runanuparidhāvati
it keeps circling aroundanuparivattati;
just·these + theseevamevime
sirsbhonto
ascetic·and·brahminsamaṇabrāhmaṇā
from fear of substantial realitysakkāyabhayā
from disgust with substantial realitysakkāyaparijegucchā
around substantial reality itselfsakkāyaññeva
along·around·runanuparidhāvanti
they keep circling aroundanuparivattanti.
that this‘Tayidaṁ
conditionedsaṅkhataṁ
crudeoḷārikaṁ
there isatthi
indeedkho
butpana
of conditionssaṅkhārānaṁ
cessationnirodho
that is realatthetan’ti—
thusiti
having understoodviditvā
of thattassa
escape·seeingnissaraṇadassāvī
thus·gonetathāgato
gone beyond thattadupātivatto.
whoeverYe indeedhi anykeci, O monksbhikkhave, asceticssamaṇā orvā brahminsbrāhmaṇā orvā final-end·speculatingaparantakappikā theorizing about the final endaparantānudiṭṭhino the final endaparantaṁ concerningārabbha various·hypothesesanekavihitāni proposalsadhivuttipadāni towards·speakabhivadanti, allsabbe theyte just theseimāneva five topicspañcāyatanāni towards·speakabhivadanti of theseetesaṁ orvā one or otheraññataraṁ.
there areSanti,
O monksbhikkhave,
someeke
ascetics and brahminssamaṇabrāhmaṇā
speculators about the first beginningpubbantakappikā
theorizers about the first beginningpubbantānudiṭṭhino
concerning the first beginningpubbantaṁ
concerningārabbha
variousanekavihitāni
hypothesesadhivuttipadāni
they proposeabhivadanti.
eternal‘Sassato
selfattā
andca
cosmosloko
andca,
this onlyidameva
truthsaccaṁ
everything else is wrongmoghamaññan’ti—
thisittheke
they proposeabhivadanti,
not eternal‘asassato
selfattā
andca
cosmosloko
andca,
this onlyidameva
truthsaccaṁ
everything else is wrongmoghamaññan’ti—
thisittheke
they proposeabhivadanti,
eternal‘sassato
andca
not eternalasassato
andca
selfattā
andca
cosmosloko
andca,
this onlyidameva
truthsaccaṁ
everything else is wrongmoghamaññan’ti—
thisittheke
they proposeabhivadanti,
neither eternal‘nevasassato
nor not eternalnāsassato
selfattā
andca
cosmosloko
andca,
this onlyidameva
truthsaccaṁ
everything else is wrongmoghamaññan’ti—
thisittheke
they proposeabhivadanti,
finite‘antavā
selfattā
andca
cosmosloko
andca,
this onlyidameva
truthsaccaṁ
everything else is wrongmoghamaññan’ti—
thisittheke
they proposeabhivadanti,
infinite‘anantavā
selfattā
andca
cosmosloko
andca,
this onlyidameva
truthsaccaṁ
everything else is wrongmoghamaññan’ti—
thisittheke
they proposeabhivadanti,
finite‘antavā
andca
infiniteanantavā
andca
selfattā
andca
cosmosloko
andca,
this onlyidameva
truthsaccaṁ
everything else is wrongmoghamaññan’ti—
thisittheke
they proposeabhivadanti,
neither finite‘nevantavā
nor infinitenānantavā
selfattā
andca
cosmosloko
andca,
this onlyidameva
truthsaccaṁ
everything else is wrongmoghamaññan’ti—
some asceticsittheke
towards·sayabhivadanti,
unified in perception‘ekattasaññī
selfattā
andca
cosmosloko
and,ca,
this·veryidameva
truthsaccaṁ
everything else is falsemoghamaññan’ti—
some asceticsittheke
towards·sayabhivadanti,
diverse in perception‘nānattasaññī
selfattā
andca
cosmosloko
and,ca,
this·veryidameva
truthsaccaṁ
everything else is falsemoghamaññan’ti—
some asceticsittheke
towards·sayabhivadanti,
having limited perception‘parittasaññī
selfattā
andca
cosmosloko
and,ca,
this·veryidameva
truthsaccaṁ
everything else is falsemoghamaññan’ti—
some asceticsittheke
towards·sayabhivadanti,
having limitless perception‘appamāṇasaññī
selfattā
andca
cosmosloko
and,ca,
this·veryidameva
truthsaccaṁ
everything else is falsemoghamaññan’ti—
some asceticsittheke
towards·sayabhivadanti,
experiencing nothing but happiness‘ekantasukhī
selfattā
andca
cosmosloko
and,ca,
this·veryidameva
truthsaccaṁ
everything else is falsemoghamaññan’ti—
some asceticsittheke
towards·sayabhivadanti,
experiencing absolute suffering‘ekantadukkhī
selfattā
andca
cosmosloko
and,ca,
this·veryidameva
truthsaccaṁ
everything else is falsemoghamaññan’ti—
some asceticsittheke
towards·sayabhivadanti,
experiencing both happiness and suffering‘sukhadukkhī
selfattā
andca
cosmosloko
and,ca,
this·veryidameva
truthsaccaṁ
everything else is falsemoghamaññan’ti—
some asceticsittheke
towards·sayabhivadanti,
experiencing neither happiness nor suffering‘adukkhamasukhī
selfattā
andca
cosmosloko
and,ca,
this·veryidameva
truthsaccaṁ
everything else is falsemoghamaññan’ti—
some asceticsittheke
towards·sayabhivadanti.
thereTatra,
monksbhikkhave,
whoye
thosete
ascetic + brahminsamaṇabrāhmaṇā
thus·sayevaṁvādino
holding such a viewevaṁdiṭṭhino:
eternal‘sassato
the selfattā
andca
the cosmosloko
andca,
this + veryidameva
truthsaccaṁ
anything else is futilemoghamaññan’ti,
for themtesaṁ
indeedvata
apart from faith itselfaññatreva
from faithsaddhāya
apart fromaññatra
from endorsementruciyā
apart fromaññatra
from oral transmissionanussavā
apart fromaññatra
reasoned·thoughtākāraparivitakkā
apart fromaññatra
view·deliberation·acceptancediṭṭhinijjhānakkhantiyā
personal·verypaccattaṁyeva
knowledgeñāṇaṁ
will bebhavissati
pureparisuddhaṁ
bright—that is notpariyodātanti—netaṁ
a possibilityṭhānaṁ
existsvijjati.
personalPaccattaṁ
indeedkho
butpana,
monksbhikkhave,
in knowledgeñāṇe
not·beasati
pureparisuddhe
brightpariyodāte
which + evenyadapi
thosete
honorablebhonto
ascetic + brahminsamaṇabrāhmaṇā
theretattha
knowledge·portion·only + veryñāṇabhāgamattameva
they illuminatepariyodapenti
that + tootadapi
of themtesaṁ
of the honorablebhavataṁ
ascetic + brahminsamaṇabrāhmaṇānaṁ
is said to be graspingupādānamakkhāyati.
that too‘Tayidaṁ
conditionedsaṅkhataṁ
coarseoḷārikaṁ
there isatthi
indeedkho
butpana
of conditionssaṅkhārānaṁ
the cessationnirodho
this is realatthetan’ti—
thusiti
having understoodviditvā
of ittassa
escape + seeingnissaraṇadassāvī
thus·gonetathāgato
has gone beyond thattadupātivatto.
thereTatra,
monksbhikkhave,
whoye
thosete
ascetics and brahminssamaṇabrāhmaṇā
holding such a doctrineevaṁvādino
holding such a viewevaṁdiṭṭhino:
not eternal‘asassato
selfattā
andca
worldloko
andca,
this onlyidameva
truthsaccaṁ
foolish is the othermoghamaññan’ti
ellipsis…pe…
eternalsassato
andca
not eternalasassato
andca
selfattā
andca
worldloko
andca
ellipsis…
neither eternalnevasassato
nor not eternalnāsassato
selfattā
andca
worldloko
andca
ellipsis…
finiteantavā
selfattā
andca
worldloko
andca
ellipsis…
infiniteanantavā
selfattā
andca
worldloko
andca
ellipsis…
finiteantavā
andca
infiniteanantavā
andca
selfattā
andca
worldloko
andca
ellipsis…
neither finitenevantavā
nor infinitenānantavā
selfattā
andca
worldloko
andca
ellipsis…
of unified perceptionekattasaññī
selfattā
andca
worldloko
andca
ellipsis…
of diverse perceptionnānattasaññī
selfattā
andca
worldloko
andca
ellipsis…
of limited perceptionparittasaññī
selfattā
andca
worldloko
andca
ellipsis…
of limitless perceptionappamāṇasaññī
selfattā
andca
worldloko
andca
ellipsis…
experiencing only happinessekantasukhī
selfattā
andca
worldloko
andca
ellipsis…
experiencing only sufferingekantadukkhī
selfattā
andca
worldloko
andca
ellipsis…
‹ Previous · Page 3 of 4 · Next ›
Lite mode — plain HTML for e-readers and old browsers. Full version